Flamingnet Student Book Reviewer Alice O'Grady
A little like reading Elements of Style on
amphetamines, Joy Writing by Kenn Amdahl,
cascades over its pages with enthusiasm for
writing. I wanted to take up my pen and buy a box
of yellow tablets before I finished reading it.
Yellow highlights throughout my copy remind me
that there are other writers that I want to read.
The examples he chooses are engaging and witty.
Much of his advice is common sense: "Revising
means making choices." Some of his advice is
surprising, "Let yourself write badly when you
create first drafts" And some of his advice is
phrased in a silly way, "the poet must distract
the Colonel Klink/editor within himself. Simply
telling him to wait in the closet isn't enough,
we need him in a different time zone." Most of it
is practical; join a writing group. And all of it
is written in an intimate, conversational tone as
if Kenn were talking directly to the reader. Joy
Writing is 160 pages of inspiration for budding
writers.
Alice O'Grady, English Teacher, Wilson HS,
Long Beach, CA
Flamingnet Student Book Reviewer William Patterson
As a high school creative writing teacher, I
know something about the difficulty of talking at
a captive, but not necessarily captivated,
audience about the joys of reading and writing
literature. As a creative writer myself, I know
something about the difficulty of finding a
helpful text on the same subject. That being
said, I found Amdahl'(then again - I already
enjoy writing and teaching quite a bit).
Though I did not find the cover image and the
multi-colored font of its title attractive, upon
opening the text at random and reading around
before I went back to the beginning to give it a
thorough read I found Amdahl's prose to be
straightforward and seemingly honest and his
examples to be helpful. The key to guidebooks
such as this is threefold: organization,
relevance and variance of example, and brevity of
personal anecdote. Amdahl's text fares well in
these areas.
The text's sections are well organized (and
usually well titled-this is more important than
one might think for younger readers/writers) and
provides short chapters with relevant and variant
topics and examples. For this reason the text
applies well to a variety of younger writers with
varying tendencies, tastes, and needs. Although
Amdahl cannot avoid the personal anecdote (after
all it is his book) he does so with some
restraint and does keep the discussion
interesting.
To conclude this and keep it short, I can
recommend this book to young adults and teachers
of young adults who want to become more effective
and more appreciative writers. It doesn't answer
all the questions (nothing does), but it can
provide the needed push to get more words on the
pages, and it can help many begin to solve the
problems of the empty page.
William Patterson,
Lawrence HS,
English Department,
Lawrence, Kansas
15 February 2006